CULTURE — February 24, 2026
Hasht-e Subh Commentary Warns Silencing Art Leaves History Ashamed
Hasht-e Subh published a commentary decrying the suppression of arts and culture, warning of a soulless society and calling for policy revival through consultation with cultural luminaries.
The Ehtebar Desk — originates with Hasht-e Subh — 2 min read

A commentary published by Hasht-e Subh argues that when leaders treat art as marginal and allocate no budgets to books, theater, cinema or music, society loses the spirit of life. The piece describes scenarios where musical instruments are broken, voices silenced, dance and song labeled 'haram,' and politicians avoid cultural festivals, viewing them as threats. It criticizes education systems stripped of art, philosophy and global cultural history, depriving youth of beauty, criticism, imagination and creation. Simple joys like listening to music or dancing at gatherings are portrayed as deemed sinful.
The article contends that without a grand cultural and artistic policy or cultural diplomacy, the country cannot engage the world through art. It notes that television, radio, news and magazines broadcast only one-sided religious content, silencing diverse voices, particularly those of women. Words like 'love,' 'affection' and 'friendship' are said to be treated as crimes, turning society into a 'silent prison' where humanity is imprisoned.
Such a society may appear orderly but is described as cold, soulless, with monologue replacing dialogue, censorship supplanting criticism, and fear stifling creativity. Artists fall silent or migrate, and women are deprived of effective societal roles, leading to a 'colorless and tuneless' community that 'rots from within.' Art is called the 'breath of life' and love the 'essence of being human.'
In conclusion, the commentary urges leaders, invoking figures like Rumi, Alisher Navoi, Rabia Balkhi, Jamaluddin Afghani and others, to consult educators, scholars, writers and artists before historical shame brings irreparable consequences. It states history will judge, advocating 'saving culture, saving humanity.'
Read the original reporting at Hasht-e Subh →
Reliability assessment
Single-source opinion piece consisting of rhetorical critique and general arguments without specific, checkable facts, events, named officials, locations or numbers.
The source language mixes facts with framing or advocacy wording. Phrases like 'instruments are broken, voices silenced and label "haram" on dance,' 'society turns into a silent prison,' and 'society rots from within; art is the breath of life' use emotional framing, hyperbole and advocacy to criticize cultural policies.
Across the newsrooms
Filed by
Hasht-e Subh
Originating
Filed under
Culture — Afghanistan, arts, culture, censorship, Hasht-e Subh
Spotted an error or have more on this story? Tip the desk on Telegram → or WhatsApp →.
Reader supported
Keep Ehtebar running
Every published story uses paid tools to translate reporting, compare sources, extract claims, and produce a clearer read on Afghanistan. Reader support helps keep that work independent.
€5
helps cover daily verification runs
€15
supports a week of source comparison
€50
keeps independent analysis moving



