INTERNATIONAL — May 5, 2026
Former Australian Soldier and Legal Expert Call for Judicial Review in War Crimes Case
A former Australian soldier and a legal expert are urging a transparent judicial review of war crimes allegations against former special forces officer Ben Roberts-Smith, stating that following orders is not a valid legal defense. Roberts-Smith, who faces five charges related to his service in Afghanistan, is scheduled for a court hearing in Sydney on June 2.
The Ehtebar Desk — originates with ToloNews — 2 min read

A former member of the Australian Defence Force and a legal expert have called for a thorough judicial process regarding war crimes allegations against former special forces officer Ben Roberts-Smith, emphasizing that obeying military commands does not excuse unlawful conduct. The former service member, who requested anonymity, argued that the defense of following orders is invalid under international law and urged authorities to conduct a comprehensive review of the case.
Roberts-Smith faces accusations of five war crimes allegedly committed during military deployments in Afghanistan. He was taken into custody in Sydney on April 17. His next court appearance is scheduled for June 2 in the same city, where procedural matters related to the ongoing case will be addressed.
Legal expert Rohullah Sakhizada stated that the allegations warrant scrutiny by international judicial bodies, including courts based in The Hague. He noted that established international legal frameworks require independent examination of such claims to ensure accountability and uphold the rule of law. Both the former soldier and the legal expert stressed the importance of a transparent and fair judicial process as the case moves forward.
The upcoming proceedings are expected to focus on the legal parameters surrounding the charges, with advocates maintaining that military hierarchy cannot shield individuals from prosecution for alleged violations of international humanitarian law.
Read the original reporting at ToloNews →
Reliability assessment
Single-source report that meets the reliability threshold due to direct attribution and concrete, checkable details, including named figures (Ben Roberts-Smith, Pauline Hanson, legal expert Rohullah Sakhizada), specific dates (arrest April 17, hearing June 2), and locations (Sydney). The core event is clearly documented and attributable.
The source language reads straight.
Independent web corroboration
An independent web search turned up no separate corroborating reports. Treat the account as single-sourced until more outlets pick it up.
Across the newsrooms
Filed by
ToloNews
Originating
Reported straight
Reported straight
Filed under
International — Ben Roberts-Smith, Australian Defence Force, War Crimes, International Justice, Afghanistan
Spotted an error or have more on this story? Tip the desk on Telegram → or WhatsApp →.
Reader supported
Keep Ehtebar running
Every published story uses paid tools to translate reporting, compare sources, extract claims, and produce a clearer read on Afghanistan. Reader support helps keep that work independent.
€5
helps cover daily verification runs
€15
supports a week of source comparison
€50
keeps independent analysis moving
More in International

Trump Calls on Parties in the Middle East to Remain Committed to Advancing Negotiations
— Developing

Trump Describes US-Iran Memorandum as Unconditional Surrender
— Reliable

US Ends Naval Blockade of Iran After Preliminary Agreement
— Reliable

Afghan National Executed in Iran, Rights Group Reports
— Reliable