SECURITY — March 27, 2026
Human Rights Watch Deems Pakistan Airstrike on Kabul Drug Treatment Center Illegal and Likely War Crime
Human Rights Watch has labeled Pakistan's March 16 airstrike on a Kabul drug treatment center illegal and potentially a war crime, reporting at least 143 killed with no evidence of military targets. The Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan claims higher casualties exceeding 400.
The Ehtebar Desk — originates with Ariana News — corroborated by Pajhwok, Hasht-e Subh, Afghanistan International and 2 more — 2 min read

Human Rights Watch has declared Pakistan's March 16, 2026, airstrike on the Umid drug treatment center in Kabul illegal under international humanitarian law and likely a war crime.
The facility, located at the former Camp Phoenix in eastern Kabul and operational since 2016, was struck in buildings including the dining hall, patient residential area and guard room. Many patients were gathered in the dining hall for iftar at the time of the attack, according to HRW's investigation, which included satellite imagery, witness statements and interviews with employees. The rights group found no evidence of military use at the civilian site and documented extensive destruction.
HRW reported at least 143 people killed and more than 250 wounded, mostly patients. The Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan stated over 400 were martyred and nearly 300 wounded, according to Ariana News. The center had hosted prisoners from Pul-e-Charkhi prison and those arrested on anti-drug charges, with some reported missing after the strike.
Pakistan described the strikes as precise operations against support infrastructure and ammunition depots, a claim rejected by HRW. Patricia Gossman, HRW's associate Asia director, called for an immediate impartial investigation by Pakistan.
The report comes amid rising tensions between Afghanistan and Pakistan.
Read the original reporting at Ariana News →
Reliability assessment
Corroborated by 6 independent Afghan outlets reporting Human Rights Watch's on-record statement deeming the airstrike illegal and a likely war crime; casualty figures range from 143 (HRW) to over 400 (Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan).
The source language mixes facts with framing or advocacy wording. Ariana News: "شهید" (martyred), repeatedly used for casualties instead of neutral 'killed', adds emotional and ideological framing common in advocacy contexts.
Independent web corroboration
An independent web search turned up no separate corroborating reports. Treat the account as single-sourced until more outlets pick it up.
Across the newsrooms
Where reports agree
- Pakistan airstrike on Umid/Omid drug treatment center in Kabul on March 16, 2026
- HRW calls attack illegal and potential war crime based on investigation including satellite imagery and witness statements
- HRW casualty figures: at least 143 killed, over 250 wounded, mostly patients
- Center at former Camp Phoenix, operating since 2016
- Targeted dining hall (patients at iftar), patient housing, guard room
- HRW: no evidence of military use; calls for Pakistani investigation
Where reports differ
- Casualty figures: HRW 143+ killed vs. Islamic Emirate >400 killed
- Pakistan's claim of targeting infrastructure/ammo depots (disputed by HRW; only in Amu TV)
- Additional details like UN on teen area destruction, prisoners/missing persons (only Amu TV)
Filed by 6 outlets
Ariana News
Originating
Framed
Framed
Pajhwok
Reported straight
Reported straight
Hasht-e Subh
Reported straight
Reported straight
Afghanistan International
Reported straight
Reported straight
RTA
Reported straight
Reported straight
Amu TV
Reported straight
Reported straight
Filed under
Security — Human Rights Watch, Pakistan, Kabul, Umid Center, Camp Phoenix
Spotted an error or have more on this story? Tip the desk on Telegram → or WhatsApp →.
Reader supported
Keep Ehtebar running
Every published story uses paid tools to translate reporting, compare sources, extract claims, and produce a clearer read on Afghanistan. Reader support helps keep that work independent.
€5
helps cover daily verification runs
€15
supports a week of source comparison
€50
keeps independent analysis moving



