POLITICS — March 19, 2026
Taliban Arrest Shia Clerics in Herat for Opposing Eid al-Fitr Announcement
Taliban authorities in Herat arrested Shia clerics including Muhammad Rouhani, Khudadad Ehsani, and Muhammad Akbari after they refused to endorse the group's declaration of Thursday as Eid al-Fitr, citing Shia jurisprudence. The move contrasts with most Islamic countries, including Saudi Arabia, which observed the holiday on Friday.
The Ehtebar Desk — originates with Afghanistan International — 2 min read

Taliban authorities in Herat arrested several Shia clerics after they refused to commit to celebrating Eid al-Fitr on Thursday as declared by the Taliban, according to sources.
The Taliban's Hajj and Endowments Directorate in Herat held a meeting on Tuesday with mullah imams of mosques and members of the Shia Ulema Council, sources said. Officials presented a written document asking attendees to sign and pledge to observe Eid according to the Taliban's announcement. The Shia scholars declined, stating that the determination of Eid and fasting days in Shia jurisprudence follows decisions by marja' taqlid.
During the meeting, Taliban forces arrested Muhammad Rouhani, head of seminaries in southwestern Afghanistan and head of Sadighiyeh Seminary, sources said. On Wednesday, they also arrested Khudadad Ehsani, representative of Ayatollah Mohaqqeq Kabuli and preacher at al-Mehdi Jibril Mosque, as well as Muhammad Akbari, former head of the Jibril Ulema Council, and several other Shia scholars in Herat. The detainees were transferred to prison.
The Taliban declared Thursday as the first day of Eid al-Fitr, differing from most Islamic countries. Saudi Arabia set the holiday for Friday, 29 Hoot.
Read the original reporting at Afghanistan International →
Reliability assessment
Single source with concrete details on named individuals, locations, and timing, but attribution relies entirely on unnamed/anonymous 'sources'; core event of arrests unconfirmed by independent outlets.
The source language mixes facts with framing or advocacy wording. Afghanistan International: 'contrary to other Islamic countries' and 'unlike most countries of the Islamic world' frame the Taliban's Eid declaration as an outlier deviation from the Islamic norm, introducing mild opinionated contrast.
Across the newsrooms
Filed by
Afghanistan International
Originating
Framed
Framed
Filed under
Politics — Taliban, Herat, Shia clerics, Eid al-Fitr, arrests
Spotted an error or have more on this story? Tip the desk on Telegram → or WhatsApp →.
Reader supported
Keep Ehtebar running
Every published story uses paid tools to translate reporting, compare sources, extract claims, and produce a clearer read on Afghanistan. Reader support helps keep that work independent.
€5
helps cover daily verification runs
€15
supports a week of source comparison
€50
keeps independent analysis moving
More in Politics

Islamic Emirate Urges Realistic Evaluations of Afghanistan
— Reliable

Taliban Minister Says Power Has Not Been Loyal to Afghanistan's Past Rulers
— Reliable

Afghanistan's UN Representative Criticizes Taliban Smartphone Ban
— Reliable

Afghan Interior Ministry to Stop Issuing License Plates for Left-Hand Drive Vehicles
— Reliable